JP EN
NSFW SFW
DLsite FANZA
SELECTED BY THE RECORD ALONE

EROMANGA
HALL OF FAME

The ero-manga hall of fame, chosen by the record alone
The Hall ── 141 authors ・ 137 circles ・ 442 works
NEW10.27Research Paper No. 2, “How Many Copies Does a Doujin Ero-Manga Sell?”, is published→
EHOF Circle Hall Works Hall Author Hall Works Hall Publishers The Paper Era Selection Criteria JPEN NSFWSFW DLsiteFANZA
HALL OF FAME ・ COMMERCIAL WORK

窓際のタバ子さん

鈴木狂太郎
No.100 ・ Commercial Works Hall
DENDO SCORE 86.32
RANK No.100
RATINGS 4,233
4★ OVER 3,917
AVERAGE ★4.66
RELEASED 2020

ヒット出版社 ・ Series: 窓際のタバ子さん 単行本

CERTIFICATE No. 0492

Share on 𝕏
窓際のタバ子さん
大賞'20 3位
View at the store

The destination store can be switched with the DLsite / FANZA toggle at the top right, where a match exists. This site takes part in affiliate programmes.

Preview on FANZA →

The preview opens in the viewer provided by FANZA Books (these links are outside the DLsite / FANZA toggle). Whether a preview appears follows the publisher's own policy: works from publishers that do not permit previews carry no such link.

APPRECIATION ── BY EHOF

Some adult comics send their readers away talking first about the story. Madogiwa no Tabako-san is one of them, and the weight of its storytelling made it its author's signature book and brought it into the hall.

A girl smoking outside a man's room offers him a bargain if he will keep her smoking to himself. She then disappears, and two years later she comes back, no longer in elementary school but in middle school. It is an adult serial whose official genre tags include loli, and it carries heavy subject matter: a wide age gap, a troubled home, compensated dating, and a relationship that begins without consent. A single comic short story completes the volume.

What readers single out, almost with one voice, is how the story unfolds. As it goes on, the reasons the girl kept coming to the man's room and the family circumstances closing in on her come to light, and the man begins to act on her behalf. Many read its structure, which carries heavy material yet closes warmly, as the human drama of one girl, bearing out the publisher's billing of the author as a born storyteller. The appealing character designs and the strength of the drawing are mentioned again and again.

Suzuki Kyotaro debuted in COMIC Aun in 2008 and was known from the start for draftsmanship. After a run of bright, comic books, the artist turned to heavy human drama in this volume, the first in two years, published twelve years after that debut.

It entered through the sales gate. In the Eromanga Taisho for 2020 it tied for third place, and it ranks 100th in the commercial hall.

The figures are an automated tally of public data from DLsite (commercial) and FANZA Books; nothing is adjusted by hand. The score and the ranking follow the formulas published in full in the Selection Criteria. The appreciation text is written by EHOF and has no connection to the rights holders or the retailer.

← No.100ふわとろ受精ちゅーどく! Commercial Works Hall No.102 →Brandish2